Provides that a federal court exercising diversity jurisdiction over a claim based on a statecreated right or obligation must apply the substantive law of the state and federal procedural law. What is the erie doctrine and what does it mean for the. The erie doctrine is based on the supreme courts holding in erie r. Common law is law that is the result of judicial decisions rather than statutes or laws enacted by a legislature. It mandates that a federal court must apply state substantive law in diversity jurisdiction cases. Coggle flowchart for erie doctrine professor nathenson. To speak to a customer service representative, please call. This article thus provides a coherent doctrinal framework for considering the challenges erie may face in the years to come. Tompkins was decided seventy years ago, federal courts today are seen as more favorable to corporate and business interests than many of their statecourt brethren. Tompkins was decided seventy years ago, federal courts today are seen as more favorable to corporate. To speak to a customer service representative, please call 814. It has been accepted for inclusion in indiana law journal by an authorized editor of digital.
Tyson, the court does not hold unconstitutional 34 of the federal judiciary act of 1789 or any other act of congress. Erie at e choice of law across the disciplines september 14, 2018. Erie doctrine law and legal definition the erie doctrine comes from a case called erie railroad co. Also, different teachers may have different approaches.
Opinion by judge tallman summary writ of mandamus erie doctrine the panel granted a. The erie doctrine is a fundamental legal doctrine in civil procedure. The erie doctrine and related doctrines are difficult topics, ones that are not easily or accurately captured in a simple flowchart. The erie doctrine encompasses, on its face, a judicial choiceoflaw methodology, commonly understood to embrace all situations in which a federal court must choose between. Erie, the class action fairness act, and some federalism. Table of contents negligence duty causation strict liability intentional. How a conflicts perspective can aid the analysis, 74 notre dame l. Rule and state law necessitating application of the erie doctrine in the first place. But translating this idea into doctrine has been a difficult task. In a conflicts scenario, the laws of two or more states are evoked, and there must be a significant difference in the outcome of the case based on which law is applied. Erie doctrine and choice of law history of the erie. Michael morley has many skills we admire in a scholar. B conflicts with the state law or policy which does not violate the rea see rea below.
The erie doctrine comes from a case called erie railroad co. The doctrine states that the federal courts, when confronted with the issue of whether to apply federal or state law in a lawsuit, must apply state law on issues of substantive law. The erie doctrine and related doctrines are difficult topics, ones. We welcome your comments and suggestions about and the erie timesnews. To determine whether there is a conflict, we must examine the purpose and scope. In the course of construction unresolved disputes arose, which resulted in wesley withholding. Erie, the class action fairness act, and some federalism implications of diversity jurisdiction david marcus abstract the class action fairness act of 2005 cafa expands diversity jurisdiction to allow most significant class actions based on state law to proceed in federal court. You can also click here to see the coggle at coggle. Erie doctrine civil procedure civ pro with barton at. The doctrine that was set forth as a result of erie v. Civil procedure outline erie doctrine abridged erie in diversity cases in federal court, the court must apply federal procedural law but state substantive law, including statecreated common lawmostly. Erie doctrine and bankruptcy this influence extends well beyond federal law.
The architecture of concurrent jurisdiction and the erie doctrine. Brief overview of why you need to use erie, the point of it, and what you think the outcome will be. The liability of a railroad company for injury caused by negligent operation of its train to a. This is bens final issue as managing editor of the erie reader. It proposes a theory that reconciles the reasoning of justice brandeis erie opinion with the subsequent evolution of the erie doctrine and federal judicial power generally. Erie doctrine law and legal definition uslegal, inc. Although the bankruptcy code code7 is a comprehensive federal statute, it essen tially establishes a method for. Applying erie becomes even more complicated once you throw in the federal. If it is, the court must apply the hannarea line of cases. Supreme court held that if a federal court is hearing a state claim because it has diversity jurisdiction, the substantive common law of the state applies. The erie doctrine in equity louisiana state university. Introduction to choice of law, vertical and horizontal.
Supreme court held that if a federal court is hearing a state claim because it has diversity. The erie doctrine stems from the longstanding debate over state rights and federal power that has existed since the united states was founded. Opinion by judge tallman summary writ of mandamus erie doctrine the panel granted a petition for a writ of mandamus brought by the county of orange, california, and directed the district court to deny tata america international. First, it is important to note that a choice of law scenario can arise in state court while the application of the erie doctrine is limited to disputes in the federal courts. Erie doctrine and choice of law choice of law lawshelf. Erie at e choice of law across the disciplines september. The erie doctrine basically stands for the proposition that a federal court, in exercise of its diversity jurisdiction, must apply state substantive law and federal procedural law. The erie doctrine is a fundamental legal doctrine of civil procedure in the united states which. A federal court sitting in diversity must use forum state law if it is necessary to avoid forum shopping and the inequitable administration of the laws. Erie, the class action fairness act, and some federalism implications of diversity jurisdiction david marcus abstract the class action fairness act of 2005 cafa expands. This category is for court cases in the united states dealing with the erie doctrine. It merely declares that, by applying the doctrine of that case, rights which are reserved by the constitution to the several states have been invaded.
Megan labelle catholic, an erie approach to privilege doctrine. But we arent proerie because some of us were born here. According to erie, federal courts must defer to state supreme courts concerning the content and scope of state law. Model answer to sample erie question is the illinois statue in direct conflict with either rule 17b or rule a. The erie doctrine is a fundamental legal doctrine of civil procedure in the united states which mandates that a federal court called upon to resolve a dispute not directly implicating a federal question most commonly when sitting in diversity jurisdiction, but also when applying supplemental jurisdiction to claims factually related to a federal question or in an adversary proceeding in. The reign of swift was terminated by the supreme courts decision in erie r. Sample erie question professor arthur wesley a citizen of illinois made an agreement with cranmer co. Tompkins 1938 that federal courts hearing issues other than those surrounding the u. Anyone have any good sample answers for civ pro erie. Tompkins doctrine which compels a federal district court, on. Erie doctrine flow chart hanna by prezi user on prezi. There was an accident and he lost an arm, so he sued.
That means that new yorks statute of limitations applies to tompkinss action only if the new york court of appeals says it does. A federal court sitting in diversity must use forum state law if it is necessary to avoid forum shopping. This note introduces you to choice of vertical the erie doctrine and horizontal choice of law. Tompkins in 1938, requires federal courts presiding over cases that involve a state law issue to apply the states.
Civil procedure professor arthur sample erie question wesley. Pages in category united states erie doctrine the following 10 pages are in this category, out of 10 total. Tompkins that except in matters governed by the federal consti tution or by acts of congress, the law to be applied in any case is the. We all remember the twin aims of the erie rule from firstyear civil procedure. Considered a victory for states rights advocates, the erie doctrine burdens federal judges with becoming experts in federal jurisprudence as well as in the various state jurisprudences from which they. The erie doctrine is a fundamental legal doctrine of civil procedure in the united states which mandates that a federal court called upon to resolve a dispute not directly implicating a federal question most.
Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. This is the approach that i like to use, though i recognize that offers may reasonably take other approaches. This should be a simple answer like, because the rule states that you can use up to 10 depositions, it is procedural. He will be continuing with us as a columnist and contributing editor, and he has set the stage admirably. Weintraubt the focus here is upon that aspect of the erie r. Heres a coggle flowchart for the erie doctrine and related issues such as rea analysis. The erie doctrine encompasses, on its face, a judicial choiceoflaw methodology, commonly understood to embrace all situations in which a federal court must choose between federal or state law. Winik, and the other terrific editors at the yale law journal. First, it is important to note that a choice of law scenario can arise in state court while the application of the erie doctrine is limited to disputes in the federal courts in a conflicts scenario, the laws of two or. The erie doctrine, based on the united states supreme court decision in erie railroad co. Erie and federalism brennan courtroom 180 moderator.
Tompkins doctrine which compels a federal district court, on issues not governed by federal law, to apply the conflict of laws rules of the state in which it sits. Everyone knows that, writes cory vaillancourt in this issues upfront. I should warn you that along with the arising under material and preclusion, i think this is the most. The erie doctrine and state conflict of laws rules digital. Review of civil procedure ii, professor ira steven nathenson.
1122 1391 788 1052 209 1127 1437 840 1005 1360 179 1348 453 1353 1273 947 213 140 1112 402 728 996 1444 1261 151 290 1505 975 1111 860 1209 320 37 1190 677